Sherzer Insurance

Port Orange/ South Daytona

(Original Location Since 1979)

Address: 3853 South Nova Rd.

Port Orange, FL 32127

Phone: 386-788-3500

Daytona Beach

(N. Daytona, LPGA, Margaritaville, Ormond Beach and Flagler)

Address: 110 Integra Breeze Ln. #1C   Daytona Beach, FL 32117

Phone: 386-868-2121

Cape Coral

(Serving all of Southwest Florida)

Address: 1227 Del Prado Blvd S Suite 201

Cape Coral, FL 33990

Phone: 239-673-9301

Florida's Trusted Independent Insurance Agency

Get a Quote!

The Independent Insurance Agency That Prioritizes You

Sherzer Insurance prioritizes safeguarding what matters most to you. Our goal is clear: deliver personalized insurance options that meet your specific requirements. With a commitment to transparency and client satisfaction, our seasoned professionals work diligently to protect your personal, residential, automotive, recreational, and business investments. With three locations, we proudly serve our clients throughout Florida. Discover our diverse insurance offerings and allow us to assist you in securing peace of mind with dependable protection.

Port Orange & Daytona Staff

Breathtaking colors of our planet
Button

Cape Coral Staff

Portraits of people from around the globe
Button

Our Insurance Services

A stack of id cards with a picture of a person on them.
Learn More
A black and white silhouette of a car on a white background.
Learn More
A line icon of a person in a circle surrounded by houses.
Learn More
A black and white icon of a store with a awning.
Learn More
A black and white icon of a document with an umbrella and a check mark.
Learn More
A black and white icon of a document with an umbrella and a check mark.
Learn More

Why You Can Trust Sherzer Insurance

No one can predict the future, and that’s why we have insurance. As an independent insurance agency, we do the difficult work of finding the best rates for your specific needs. We want you to spend less time worrying if you’re properly insured and more time enjoying your life. No one can predict the future, but Sherzer Insurance can make sure it’s protected. We have three locations in Daytona Beach, Port Orange, and Cape Coral so that we can help our clients throughout all of Florida.

Sherzer Insurance

See Why Our Clients Have Trusted Our Insurance Team Since 1979

  • A white background with a few lines on it

    ⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐


    This appears to be a great office.  Tyler was extremely helpful and professional.  The whole team seems like they love their jobs and seem to put customer service first. I was with Geico for about 30 years and all I ever received was excuses,  terrible customer service and huge premium increases. I'm happy so far, I'll let you know in 6 months.  Thanks again Tyler


    - Patrice H.

  • A white background with a few lines on it

    ⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐


    We have used Sherzer for years and always use Tyler for all of our insurance needs! She is the absolute best and is so quick and efficient. We couldn’t be happier with her service!


    - Gabrielle D.

    Button
  • A white background with a few lines on it

    ⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐


    Rayna Vagnier is very professional and friendly.She is 5 star.  Sherzer is one of the best insurance companies in Volusia co.


    - Debhorah W.

    Button
  • A white background with a few lines on it

    ⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐


    I needed quotes for new insurance, both Emily and Anthony helped me with all the questions I had. They took the time to explain my options. I will definitely be reaching out to them when I need to renew my insurance coverage.


    - Nichelle D.

    Button
  • A white background with a few lines on it

    ⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐


    This appears to be a great office.  Tyler was extremely helpful and professional.  The whole team seems like they love their jobs and seem to put customer service first. I was with Geico for about 30 years and all I ever received was excuses,  terrible customer service and huge premium increases. I'm happy so far, I'll let you know in 6 months.  Thanks again Tyler


    - Patrice H.

  • A white background with a few lines on it

    ⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐


    We have used Sherzer for years and always use Tyler for all of our insurance needs! She is the absolute best and is so quick and efficient. We couldn’t be happier with her service!


    - Gabrielle D.

    Button
  • A white background with a few lines on it

    ⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐


    Rayna Vagnier is very professional and friendly.She is 5 star.  Sherzer is one of the best insurance companies in Volusia co.


    - Debhorah W.

    Button
  • A white background with a few lines on it

    ⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐


    I needed quotes for new insurance, both Emily and Anthony helped me with all the questions I had. They took the time to explain my options. I will definitely be reaching out to them when I need to renew my insurance coverage.


    - Nichelle D.

    Button
Share by: