Please ensure Javascript is enabled for purposes of website accessibility Our Company - Sherzer & Associates Insurance Agency


Putting our clients’ needs first, always.

Saving You Money Since 1979

Sherzer Insurance, a local, independent agency, was founded in Daytona Beach in 1979 by Marvin Sherzer. What began as a small auto insurance agency eventually grew into several agencies in Georgia, Kentucky, Oklahoma, and California. After eventually selling the agencies, Mr. Sherzer retired back to the Daytona Beach area where he sold his original location to Jim Allender in 2008.

Mr. Allender began his career in Charlotte County, FL where he was trained at Insurance Depot, an independent agency, writing home, auto, and commercial liability. It was there that he formed many relationships with top companies in Florida.

Upon relocation to Daytona Beach to purchase Sherzer Insurance, Mr. Allender brought his expertise of homeowners and commercial liability, as well as his relationships with other A-rated national and Florida-based companies, in order to expand customer options in Volusia County.

In 2016 Mr. Allender partnered with his sister, April Allender, to open a branch of Sherzer in Southwest Florida in order to serve Lee, Charlotte, and Collier counties. With both the Daytona and Cape Coral area offices, Sherzer Insurance can serve their clients' needs on both the East and West Coasts of Florida. Sherzer is also an active member in the local Chamber of Commerce in both cities.

At Sherzer “We Shop; You Save!”

Please give one of our offices a call today. We would love to earn your business.

Icon of a house


Excellent customer service and face-to-face communication is a high priority for us. You’ll never deal with 1-800 numbers or frustrating automated messages when you work with our team. We believe that protecting every aspect of your life is a personal journey, so we want to get to know you personally. Whether it’s a new policy or just a simple question, we want to be your quick, reliable source for all things insurance.

talk to an agent

Or call for immediate assistance.